February 22, 2024

In 2017, a former US Air Force translator Winning Reality He leaked an intelligence report that revealed attempted interference by Russia in the 2016 US presidential election. While Winner acted out of his sense of patriotic duty, he committed a crime. So it’s no surprise that Winner was arrested and convicted. Shockingly, Winner received the longest prison sentence ever for the unauthorized release of government documents to the media.

FBI transcripts of Winner’s interrogation and arrest shed a grim light on the matter, showing how sexism and partisan bias played a role in the translator’s excessive sentence. that’s why Tina Sutter he decided to turn the transcript into an engaging Broadway play Is this the room?, the playwright is now turning into a movie in its debut. As in the original play, the reality It reproduces the original audio recording of Winner’s interrogation verbatim, faithful to every pause, cough, laugh and bark in the background. However, the reality it is not reproduction Is this a room?Satter gets his hands dirty in cinematic language to make the tense story even more compelling in a remarkable directorial debut.


the protagonist Sydney Sweeney As a winner, the reality it opens with an overlay of playbacks and the audio track, emphasizing how everything we see on the silver screen is taken from the original recording made by FBI agents during the raid on the translator’s home. During the winner’s poll, the reality It will remind the viewer that these are real events by adding small snippets of recordings, official documents, photos, Winner’s Instagram posts and even news programs. Meanwhile the reality it is not a documentary, Satter uses reality as raw material to constantly remind us of what Winner went through. At the same time, the director also finds creative ways to make the written passages carry weight in the story, playing with image distortions and character displacements.

See also  The 10 best clones of the franchise

While Winner will be accused of betraying his country because of his hatred of the United States, reduced to a vicious disruptor, interrogation records paint a more complex picture. The winner was angry about the election Donald Trump It’s 2016 and caught in the middle of America’s political turmoil. However, he does not fit the image of a rabid progressive, as he still keeps automatic rifles in his home for personal protection and dedicates his life to the service of the Armed Forces. There was no master plan behind Winner’s actions, he was just a man, full of contradictions, who decided to act on impulse after discovering a document so important to US history that the Senate would recognize the public interest.

Berlinale logo

RELATED: ‘Somebody I Knew’ Review: Alison Brie Goes Weak in Romantic Reflection

By giving the viewer access to Winner’s quiz interview, the reality It pays homage to a confused and insecure woman who bit off more than she could chew and was caught red-handed for a crime she didn’t realize the gravity of. the reality It also does a great job of showing how gender roles played a role in Winner’s conviction, as he is taken in by a protective group of FBI agents who show genuine admiration for his physical and intellectual achievements. Using the weight of the position, the FBI agents try to make Winner a weakling who will bend to their will, with no lawyer to advise the young woman. This, along with Winner’s explicit political preferences, made him an example to the nation of an unfair charge given his crimes.

the reality He also finds time to denounce the irresponsible action of the media regarding Winner’s whistle. Winner believed the world needed to know about this dangerous political attack, and decided to act by sending classified information to The Intercept. And the same outlet that promises to embrace whistleblowers betrays journalistic ethics by naming the source that provided them with the classified document.

A winner’s mistake would open the country to a vital debate about national security and the reliability of the electoral system. However, he was betrayed by the media, who used the leak to gain fame, before securing a harsh sentence that appears to have more to do with his gender and political preferences than the seriousness of his crime. the reality turns this complex case into a thrilling exploration of the police system, never daring to reduce his characters to the simplistic parts they would play on the news.

As a result the realityDue to space and time constraints, the film could only work with a perfect cast, which luckily it has. On that note, Sweeney gives the best performance of her career, making every little quiver and hesitation in Winner’s original audio voice a source of inspiration to bring a layered character to life. Sweeney’s Winner reflects the emotional upheaval experienced by a young woman after FBI agents appear on her doorstep. thanks to him the reality It’s a mesmerizing experience that pulls no punches and will shake any viewer’s core.

Rating: A

the reality It had its world premiere at the 2023 Berlin Film Festival.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *